Attacks On Christianity in Palestine
Photo: Mostafa Alkharouf / Anadolu Agency via Getty Images
by Jonathan Kuttab
Attacks by religious fanatics on places of worship and individuals of another religion are a well-known and despicable phenomenon. They go beyond mere racism and discrimination, in that they invoke the name of God Almighty in justifying bitter hatreds and hostilities against entire communities. Those performing the attacks do so with zeal and venom, and a feeling that they are serving God.
Attacks by religious Jews on Muslim holy places in Palestine are often recorded and noted, and they are sometimes used to explain the ongoing hostilities between the two groups and to warn of the consequences of turning an otherwise political situation into a religious conflict with devastating worldwide consequences. Indeed, it would be horribly tragic if Muslims worldwide start viewing Jews as enemies and start seeking revenge upon them in the name of God. Advocates and proponents of justice for Palestine should always be very careful to avoid such approaches and to insist on framing the situation in its proper political framework. They must not yield to the temptation of seeing it as a religious conflict between Judaism and Islam. To be sure, there are religious differences and conflicting claims to holy places, particularly in Jerusalem, and these conflicts have been used in the past to justify campaigns to conquer Jerusalem, “rid it of infidels,” and assert political control over it. This was also done by crusaders and other groups.
Recently, we have been observing a sharp rise in attacks by Jewish religious fanatics on Christian clergy, cemeteries, and holy places in Palestine, particularly in Jerusalem. These fanatics take advantage of the power of the state (Israel) to attack Christians and to assert political power and control over Jerusalem on behalf of the Jewish state.
The typical reaction in the West has been to totally ignore or downplay such attacks on Christians. One reason is an obvious one: Christians in the West feel they have very little basis for complaining against such bigotry in light of their own despicable millennia of anti-Jewish bigotry and intolerance in their own countries, which has not yet fully subsided as antisemitism continues to raise its ugly head from time to time until this day. The fact that the Christians being attacked in Palestine today are not responsible for western bigotry seems besides the point. Western Christians, who duly report and condemn every attack on synagogues and Jewish cemeteries are not as willing to note or condemn attacks on Christians in Palestine.
Yet these attacks are now becoming a more frequent phenomenon. One frequent type of attack, spitting on clerics and clergy, is literally a daily event in the Old City. One Israeli Jewish reporter, who wanted to investigate these claims, borrowed an abbot’s cassock and walked the streets of the Old City, and sure enough he was spat upon. The Israeli police apparently do nothing, even though the Old City is blanketed with surveillance cameras which record everything that happens in its streets, and given Israel's facial-recognition technology, which it is marketing to the whole world, it would be easy for them to identify the attackers.
Another manifestation is in the attacks on Christian cemeteries and churches. Hateful graffiti is sprayed on the walls, there are attempts to start fires and burn churches, and cemeteries are broken into and headstones are smashed. In one recent attack on a church in the Old City, statues of Jesus and the Virgin Mary were shattered. In a frightening incident recently, Jewish fanatics attacked the monastery of Stella Maris in Haifa, claiming that it is actually a Jewish holy site to which they want to lay claim. The conflicting claims of the three monotheistic religions, as well as the competing Christian denominations, was carefully set forth in a document referred to as the Status Quo arrangement, enacted by the Turkish Ottomans, adopted by the British, then the Jordanians, and at least formally accepted by Israel. Attempts to alter this arrangement could easily lead to religious conflict.
From a theological point of view, Christians (for the most part at least), thankfully no longer make the kind of claims that were made by Crusaders. After all, the essence of Jesus’ message was to reject the concept of an earthly kingdom. My kingdom is not of this world, he taught. He also addressed the issue of the “holy places” in his conversation with the Samaritan woman at the well. When she asked him where is the proper place to worship God, “here in Samaria or in Jerusalem?” He answered that neither is the true holy place for worship, because “God is spirit and those who worship him must worship him in spirit and in truth.”
Good theological arguments can be found also in Judaism and Islam to battle such bigotry, but the fact remains that there are those who make a practice of agitating and seeking religious domination and supremacy in the name of God. We need to use both religious arguments, rational secular arguments, and proper common sense and decency to reject such atrocious behavior and to promote religious tolerance and understanding. Political strife is bad enough. Religious bigotry on top of that would be disastrous.
FOSNA News
After a two-year hiatus, FOSNA is reinstituting its Annual August Membership Drive.
As friends of Sabeel, we stand together in solidarity, secure in our calling as an unapologetic voice for Palestine. With the international spotlight once again on Palestine/Israel, we have an unprecedented opportunity to highlight the reality that Israel, to Palestinian eyes, has never been a democracy.
The challenges before us are great, but together we are making a real difference:
We are challenging the powers of oppression and domination that humiliate and suppress the Palestinian people;
Destructive theologies, ideologies, and assumptions no longer go unchallenged;
Americans continue to grow more aware of the realities of Israeli apartheid and the settler-colonial violence on which it is built;
And, we proudly support the essential work of Sabeel in Palestine, in solidarity with all Palestinians steadfast in their demand for justice and truth.
Becoming a member of a grassroots membership organization like FOSNA means joining an international movement of committed activists, advocates, academics, individuals of conscience, clergy and lay leaders, students, and a whole host of modern-day prophets speaking truth to power and striving together for liberation, justice, and peace in the Holy Land. Our members are our strength, and we need you.
Join us in standing alongside and supporting the remarkable people of Palestine in their ongoing quest for liberation, justice, and peace:
Become a supporting member for as little as $15/year, OR
Maximize your impact as a sustaining member for as little as $5/month
Take Action!
Sign now to tell Democratic candidates: Reject support from AIPAC
(Cori Bush) Anti-Palestinian lobbying group AIPAC has influenced Congress for decades to unconditionally and uncritically support Israel’s government.
In addition to AIPAC, the group formed a new SuperPAC, called the United Democracy Project. In 2022, the United Democracy Project (UDP) intervened in ten separate Democratic primaries to defeat progressive candidates. UDP also endorsed and funded Republicans in general elections against progressive Democrats.
With these PACs and another affiliated PAC known as Democratic Majority for Israel (DMFI), AIPAC spent over $41 million attacking Democrats in the last election cycle, with much success.
Pro-Trump billionaires donated millions to these PACs in order to shape the Democratic Party in primaries and attack Democrats in general elections. This is again anti-democratic work, out of alignment with Democratic voters -- who have indicated in recent polls that they sympathize with Palestinians and do not want their taxpayer dollars to support the Israeli government’s human rights abuses.
AIPAC is not only anti-Palestinian, but also anti-progressive and anti-democracy.
Please sign now to tell Democratic candidates running for election or re-election in 2024: Do not take money from AIPAC PAC or its network of PACs (the United Democracy Project and Democratic Majority for Israel). Reject endorsements and funding from these right-wing, anti-democratic groups.
Get Involved!
We invite you to join us in the following events and activities:
August 20: Online
VFHL Film Salon: The Truth: Lost at Sea
In May 2010, an international flotilla of six unarmed civilian vessels, carrying citizens from dozens of countries (including the US), defied Israel's complete naval blockade to deliver much needed construction materials and humanitarian aid to Gaza. Under the cover of darkness, the most powerful military force in the Middle East dispatched heavily armed commandos via speedboats and helicopters to seize the Mavi Marmara, resulting in the tragic deaths of nine activists. "The Truth: LOST AT SEA" presents authentic footage and narration by a survivor to reveal the factual sequence of events, shedding light on how traditional and online media platforms manipulated and vilified human rights advocates who dedicated themselves to raising awareness about the plight of Palestinians in Gaza.
Watch the film for free at your convenience; Join the Q&A Discussion
Rifat Audeh: director, producer, activist, survivor of 2010 Gaza Freedom Flotilla
Ann Wright: Ret’d US Army Colonel, 2010, 2015, & 2016 Gaza Freedom Flotillas, 2018 & 2023 ground crew
Awni Farhat: Gaza activist, 2018 & 2023 Gaza Freedom Flotilla participant
Alex McDonald (moderator): author, educator, activist, 2018 and 2023 Gaza Freedom Flotilla participant
You must register to get the free film link and to participate in the Q&A discussion.
Weekly
Sabeel Prayer Service. Join Sabeel every Thursday (6pm Palestine) for online Bible Study, discussion, and prayer. Examine scripture in light of the ongoing realities confronting the Palestinian Church and the pursuit of Palestinian liberation.
Wave of Prayer. Subscribe to receive Sabeel's Wave of Prayer, enabling friends of Sabeel around the world to pray over issues of critical concern to the Holy Land on a weekly basis.
Kumi Now! Week 32 (August 6 to August 12) - Indigenous Rights. Kumi Now is an online gathering every Tuesday (6pm Palestine) with a guest speaking on the weekly topic. Register here.
August 9 is International Day of the World’s Indigenous Peoples. This week, Kumi Now is following U.N. Secretary-General António Guterres’s
call: “On this annual observance, let us commit to fully realizing the United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, including the rights to self-determination and to traditional lands, territories and resources.” We look at how indigenous populations around the world are struggling for their rights and what you can do so that Palestinians and all indigenous peoples can rise up.